Report: US Spends $145 Billion on Afghanistan Reconstruction, with Nearly $30 Billion Squandered

A new report reveals that the United States squandered almost one-fifth of the funds allocated to rebuild Afghanistan following the Taliban's removal from power over twenty years ago. The Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) published its final report on Wednesday, reviewing U.S. reconstruction efforts from 2002 to 2021.

The report highlights a combination of factors that contributed to the failure of U.S. attempts to transform Afghanistan into a stable democracy. It notes that the "seeds of failure" were planted long before the 2021 withdrawal of U.S. troops, which allowed the Taliban to regain control.

Part of the problem, the report states, was "early and ongoing decisions by the U.S. to support corrupt and abusive leaders," which strengthened insurgents and undermined reconstruction goals.

The financial consequences were staggering. Between $26 billion and $29.2 billion was lost due to waste, fraud, and abuse, and tens of thousands of lives were lost, including over 2,450 U.S. service members.

John Sopko, former SIGAR inspector general, described the final report as a solid summary but emphasized it could have focused more on the key lessons rather than listing all audits and investigations. SIGAR will be disbanded at the end of the month after nearly two decades of oversight.

Professor Jennifer Murtazashvili of the University of Pittsburgh highlighted the importance of SIGARs work in exposing the inefficiencies of U.S. intervention in Afghanistan, while acknowledging that American involvement did lead to some improvements in the country.

Financial Waste

The report estimates that roughly $145 billion was spent on rebuilding Afghanistan, with more than 1,300 documented instances of waste, fraud, or abuse. Waste alone accounted for 93% of the lost funds, including billions of dollars in abandoned military equipment after U.S. withdrawal and $7.3 billion spent on ineffective counternarcotics programs. An additional $4.7 billion went to stabilization efforts that failed to achieve intended goals.

Contractors handling security, infrastructure, and other projects were frequently unable to deliver results, overbilled, or were paid for incomplete work. Murtazashvili pointed to the 2009 surge under President Obama as a period when massive funding was injected into an economy unable to manage it, creating reliance on costly contractors and security arrangements.

SIGAR investigations led to 171 criminal convictions and recoveries totaling around $1.7 billion. Among the cases cited was a major tax evasion scheme by defense contractor Douglas Edelman and his wife, involving hundreds of millions of dollars in undeclared income from U.S. government contracts.

Democracy and Governance

The U.S. goal of transforming Afghanistan into a functioning democracy proved largely unattainable. Centralized governance structures limited local elections and left citizens with little real voice. Security concerns further complicated democratic processes; the 2019 presidential election saw only 10% voter turnout and widespread allegations of fraud.

Taliban Resurgence

The billions of dollars lost and the deaths of thousands of U.S. troops overshadowed any accomplishments from two decades of intervention. Murtazashvili noted that, while Afghan society has improved in some aspects, the return of the Taliban represented a dramatic setback.

Accountability and Oversight

Sopko emphasized that responsibility extended beyond presidents, pointing to congressional committees and advisors as key players who failed to ensure proper oversight. SIGARs reports demonstrate the limited effectiveness of congressional hearings, which rarely examined reconstruction issues in depth.

Lessons for the Future

The final SIGAR report serves as a warning for future reconstruction efforts in conflict zones like Gaza, Ukraine, and Syria. Experts argue that policymakers must critically assess whether similar interventions are feasible, what lessons can be applied, and how taxpayer money can be protected from waste.

Despite the setbacks, some progress was made in Afghanistan, such as improvements in education and general wellbeing, though the results were inconsistent and often inefficient. Both Sopko and Murtazashvili stress the need to learn from these experiences rather than retreat from global engagement.

Author: Sophia Brooks