Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O'Connor have returned to their hometown from Los Angeles, she confirms (Exclusive)

Caitlin O'Connor has revealed that she and her fianc, Joe Manganiello, have moved back to their hometown of Pittsburgh after living in Los Angeles for many years. In an exclusive interview, O'Connor shared that the couple feels a deep connection over their shared upbringing and are thrilled to be "back home together."

The couple, who got engaged in October 2025 following two years of dating, have settled in Mount Lebanon, a suburb of Pittsburgh. O'Connor described the move as a long-considered decision rather than a sudden change.

L.A. has been a home for both of us for over 20 years, she said. I was born in L.A., but I grew up in Pittsburgh, and Joe is from the same hometown. That shared background really connects us.

O'Connor also expressed her admiration for their new neighborhood, calling it "idyllic" and noting how safe it feels. Despite occasional work trips to Los Angeles and New York City, Pittsburgh will serve as their primary home.

The couple has been enjoying the winter season, with O'Connor joking about watching Manganiello shovel snow. Shes also looking forward to celebrating the holidays in Pittsburgh, anticipating large family gatherings as relatives either travel to the city or already live nearby.

Over the past two years, the pair have traveled extensively and have collected ornaments from over 70 cities around the world, turning their experiences into a unique collection of mementos.

Manganiello and O'Connor first fueled romance rumors in September 2023 and publicly confirmed their relationship later that year. They shared their engagement news on Instagram, highlighting the proposal, which took place on June 24, 2025.

Author’s Analysis: Caitlin O'Connor and Joe Manganiello Return to Pittsburgh

The decision by Caitlin O'Connor and Joe Manganiello to relocate from Los Angeles to Pittsburgh highlights the growing trend of celebrities prioritizing hometown connections over long-term urban careers. For O'Connor and Manganiello, shared roots and a sense of community played a decisive role in their move.

Settling in Mount Lebanon, a suburb known for safety and suburban charm, the couple emphasizes stability and family-centered living. This contrasts with their previous life in L.A., demonstrating a deliberate shift toward personal fulfillment and long-term planning rather than career-driven relocation.

While their work commitments will occasionally bring them back to Los Angeles and New York City, Pittsburgh is now positioned as their primary base. Their recent travels and collection of ornaments from over 70 cities suggest that the couple values experiences and mementos, but the choice of home reflects a prioritization of roots and lifestyle.

This move also underscores how engagement and family milestones influence major life decisions. By returning to their shared hometown, O'Connor and Manganiello are setting the stage for a life integrated with family and community traditions, reinforcing Pittsburgh as a central part of their narrative.

Sources:

• Joe Manganiello and Fiancée Caitlin O'Connor Have Left L.A. for Their Hometown, She Confirms (Exclusive)