Emma Chamberlain Explains Her Preference for Dating Musicians, Echoing Sabrina Carpenter: 'They Seem to Find Me, Not the Other Way Around'

Influencer and content creator Emma Chamberlain recently shared insights into her love life during a conversation with friend and podcaster Owen Thiele on his In Your Dreams podcast. The discussion focused on her past relationships, particularly with musicians.

Over the past five years, Chamberlain has been romantically connected to singer-songwriters Role Model (Tucker Pillsbury) and Peter McPoland. On the November 28 episode titled "I got stuffed with Emma Chamberlain," Thiele asked, "Emma, can I ask you a question? Why do you keep dating musicians?"

Chamberlain responded with humor, quoting Sabrina Carpenter: "'I swear they choose me. I'm not choosing them,'" a line from Carpenter's song Manchild. She then admitted, "No, they choose me. And I choose them a little too."

She described what she called "interesting evidence" suggesting that musicians pursue her rather than the other way around. "I have never slid into the DM of a musician. Only ever has the music man slid into mine," she joked. "I have never approached a man in music at a bar. Only ever has a man in music approached me."

When Thiele suggested she might naturally attract musicians, Chamberlain reflected, "You know what's weird? Like that does do a little something, but that's not the root of it. I kind of can't figure out what it is." She explained that her attraction isn't limited to musicians: "Like if I met a really hot baseball player, Id think it was hot that they loved what they do. It's like any guy doing something theyre passionate aboutI find that attractive."

She admitted that dating musicians may have been coincidental. Referring to her relationship with Pillsbury from 2020-2023, she said, "The first time, that was random. It was irrelevant that he made music. The second time, I didnt even know they made music at first."

Chamberlain also discussed the experience of hearing songs inspired by her relationships. "I learned about my own relationships through the music," she said. "Sometimes its illuminating, but it can be strange when you hear more in a song than in real life."

The 24-year-old influencer recently confirmed that she is currently single on her Anything Goes podcast, describing her breakup from a "serious relationship that was two years long" as deeply meaningful. She had previously been linked to Peter McPoland, with sightings during the 2024 Paris Olympics and matching Halloween costumes fueling speculation.

Author’s Commentary: Emma Chamberlain on Dating Musicians

Emma Chamberlain’s recent discussion on the In Your Dreams podcast sheds light on her romantic history and attraction patterns. Over the past five years, she has dated singer-songwriters Role Model (Tucker Pillsbury) and Peter McPoland, but she emphasizes that these connections were not a deliberate pursuit of musicians.

Chamberlain explained that, in most cases, musicians approach her rather than the other way around. She humorously noted that she has never initiated contact with a musician, whether online or in person. While she acknowledged that being approached by musicians might contribute to the trend, she stressed that her attraction is rooted in passion and dedication, regardless of the field.

She also reflected on how her relationships have been mirrored in music, calling the experience "illuminating" but occasionally disorienting. Chamberlain recently confirmed she is single, following the end of a two-year relationship, and described it as a significant personal experience.

Overall, Chamberlain’s insights highlight that her romantic choices are guided more by personal connection and admiration for ambition than by any intentional focus on musicians. The pattern appears coincidental, shaped by mutual interest rather than strategic selection.

Sources:

• Emma Chamberlain Reveals Why She Keeps Dating Musicians, Quoting Sabrina Carpenter: 'I Swear They Choose Me, I'm Not Choosing Them'