Experts skeptical about Pentagon's ability to discipline Kelly for posting video of 'illegal orders'

  1. Home
  2. Politics
  3. Experts skeptical about Pentagon's ability to discipline Kelly for posting video of 'illegal orders'
  • Last update: 12/01/2025
  • 3 min read
  • 107 Views
  • Politics

WASHINGTON (AP) The Pentagon has opened an investigation into Senator Mark Kelly over a video in which he urges U.S. troops to resist illegal orders, prompting intense legal discussion and criticism. Experts are divided: some argue the military is misinterpreting laws to target Kelly, a retired Navy pilot, while others maintain that as a sitting member of Congress, he cannot face prosecution. A group of former military prosecutors has stated that Kellys actions were lawful.

The inquiry was announced last week following former President Donald Trumps social media post accusing Kelly and five other Democratic lawmakers featured in the video of sedition punishable by death. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth clarified that the probe focuses on Kelly because he is the only retired member among the group still under military jurisdiction.

Kelly dismissed the investigation, calling it the work of bullies and insisting it would not prevent him or his colleagues from holding the administration accountable.

Stephen Vladeck, a law professor at Georgetown University, noted a rise in courts-martial involving retired service members over the past decade. While courts have debated the constitutionality of this practice, it remains permissible, with roughly a dozen such cases occurring across military branches. According to the Congressional Research Service, about 2 million people receive military retirement pay after completing 20 years of service.

Todd Huntley, a retired Navy captain and JAG officer, emphasized that prosecutions of retirees for post-retirement actions are uncommon but not unprecedented. I prosecuted an enlisted member retired for 16 years who committed assault because no other jurisdiction existed, Huntley said.

Colby Vokey, a former military prosecutor and civilian military lawyer, argued that Hegseth misapplies the Uniform Code of Military Justice. He explained that while Kelly falls under personal jurisdiction due to retirement pay, subject matter jurisdiction does not extend to actions taken in his capacity as a senator. Vokey highlighted the absurdity of applying military law to retired individuals for acts outside military service.

Patrick McLain, a retired Marine Corps judge, noted that previous retiree prosecutions were for extreme cases like fraud or child exploitation, not political speech protected by the First Amendment. Charles Dunlap, a Duke University law professor, observed that while military law can limit active-duty members speech, its application to retirees remains questionable.

The Former JAGs Working Group, a collective of former military lawyers, stated that Kelly did not violate military law. They emphasized that the video addressed lawful versus unlawful orders without inciting mutiny.

Legal precedent holds that following unlawful orders does not absolve responsibility, a principle rooted in the Nuremberg Trials. Kelly and the other lawmakers did not reference any specific orders in their video. The video also ties into broader concerns, as some Democrats question the legality of deploying National Guard troops domestically and using military forces against suspected drug operations in South America.

Michael OHanlon of the Brookings Institution suggested that any prosecution against Kelly would likely be dismissed or end in acquittal. He added that Kelly acted as a civilian lawmaker, not in a military capacity.

Constitutional experts highlight that Kellys position as a senator could prevent Pentagon action. Anthony Michael Kreis, a law professor at Georgia State University, stated that subjecting a member of Congress to disciplinary action from the Department of Defense violates the separation of powers, a safeguard established to prevent governmental overreach.

Addition from the author

Analysis: Pentagon Investigation into Senator Mark Kelly

The Pentagon's inquiry into Senator Mark Kelly over his video urging troops to resist "illegal orders" raises significant legal and constitutional questions. While Kelly is a retired Navy pilot and technically under military jurisdiction, experts widely agree that his actions as a sitting member of Congress are protected and unlikely to constitute a prosecutable offense.

Former military prosecutors and legal scholars emphasize that Kelly's video discussed the lawful distinction between legal and illegal orders without inciting mutiny or violence. Cases of retirees facing courts-martial are rare and typically involve severe criminal conduct, not political speech. Applying the Uniform Code of Military Justice to a senator for actions taken in a civilian role sets a controversial precedent.

Constitutional protections, particularly the separation of powers, further complicate any attempt to prosecute Kelly. Legal analysts note that targeting a sitting member of Congress through military channels could constitute overreach by the Pentagon and would likely be dismissed if challenged in court.

In summary, while the investigation has drawn public attention and political commentary, the consensus among legal and military experts is that Senator Kelly acted within both civilian and legal boundaries. The outcome of the inquiry is expected to reinforce existing interpretations of military jurisdiction over retirees and underscore the limits of military authority in matters involving elected officials.

Follow Us on X

Stay updated with the latest news and worldwide events by following our X page.

Open X Page

Sources:

Author: Sophia Brooks

Share This News
Florida congresswoman accuses Ruben Gallego of engaging in sexual misconduct.

Florida Congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna has accused Senator Ruben Gallego of sexual misconduct, submitting a report to Senate leadership. Gallego denies the claims, which have not led to formal invest...

04/16/2026 3 min read Politics Jackson Miller

White House Border Czar Tom Homan Calls on Catholic Church to Listen and Learn

Former Border Chief Tom Homan sharply criticized the Catholic Church's stance on immigration, urging Church leaders to "sit down and let me educate them." Homan emphasized the importance of secure bor...

04/15/2026 3 min read Politics Zoe Harrison

Jonathan Nez Reacts to President Trump's Comments on Pope Leo XIV

Jonathan Nez, former Navajo Nation president, responded to former President Trumps remarks on Pope Leo XIV, calling them deeply concerning and stressing the need for leaders to promote unity, respect,...

04/15/2026 2 min read Politics Sophia Brooks

Ted Cruz stands by Trump despite Pope's criticism

Senator Ted Cruz has expressed his neutrality amid the ongoing dispute between President Trump and Pope Leo XIV. Despite media pressure, Cruz refrained from taking sides, emphasizing that both the Pop...

04/14/2026 3 min read Politics Ethan Caldwell

Will Trump secure a better Iran deal than Obama? Here's what you need to know

As tensions over Iran's

04/12/2026 4 min read Politics Natalie Monroe

The High Stakes of a Complex Supreme Court Case this Term

The Supreme Court is set to hear Pitchford v Cain a case highlighting the tension between strict legal procedures and the fight against racial discrimination in jury selection The ruling could shape h...

04/12/2026 4 min read Politics Zoe Harrison

Expert predicts Donald Trump may dismiss Pete Hegseth next

Amid rising tensions with Iran, experts suggest President Donald Trump may remove key officials from his administration, including Pete Hegseth, if the temporary ceasefire falters, signaling potential...

04/11/2026 4 min read Politics Ethan Caldwell

Expert predicts Donald Trump may dismiss Pete Hegseth soon

Political analyst Michael J. Montgomery predicts potential shifts in the U.S. administration, highlighting the possibility of Pete Hegseth's dismissal as Secretary of Defense. This could occur if a te...

04/11/2026 4 min read Politics Connor Blake

Democrats take on external organizations flooding their primaries with campaign funds

Democratic primaries are facing a surge of outside funding as political groups back candidates in key races, shifting focus from individuals to competing interests and raising concerns over fairness a...

04/11/2026 4 min read Politics Logan Reeves

Democrats criticize Pam Bondi for handling of Epstein hearing.

House Democrats have sharply criticized former Attorney General Pam Bondi for refusing to

04/10/2026 3 min read Politics Aiden Foster