Lindsay Hubbard Criticizes Johnny Bananas for Implies They Had a Baby Together

Drama has erupted between Summer House star Lindsay Hubbard and The Challenge alum Johnny Bananas after comments made on a recent podcast.

Last month, Bananas appeared on the Hollywood Raw podcast with Dax Holt and Adam Glyn, discussing his sighting with Hubbard in November 2023, months after her split from Carl Radke. The encounter occurred during what would have been Hubbard and Radkes wedding weekend, before Radke called it off.

I knew Lindsay before she was on reality TV, Bananas explained. Back then, she worked as a publicist, and we collaborated years ago. Then we went our separate ways, I started a relationship, and later saw her on Summer House. I was thrilled for her. Shes always a great time. Things with her and Carl went south, and we reconnected and rekindled.

When asked if the reconnection was ongoing, Bananas made a surprising statement hinting they may have been intimate and that he feared Hubbards baby could be his. Hubbard announced her pregnancy in July 2024 and gave birth to daughter Gemma in December 2024.

Bananas elaborated on the podcast: The timing of when we reconnected was scary for me, especially when a few months later, Lindsay Hubbard is pregnant. I even thought about counting the days. When asked if he expected a call, he admitted, Yeah, I was waiting. I even joked about wishing I had used a condom from the sound guy. But no way her kids mine.

Hubbard responded via her Instagram Story, firmly denying any intimacy with Bananas. Dear Johnny Bananas, just to be clear, you have to actually have sex to get pregnant, and we never hooked up, she wrote. Get your attention elsewhere. My baby is way too cute to be a Bananas baby!

Bananas later replied, jokingly: Dear [Lindsay], Banana babies dont come out cutethey come out legendary yours is safe.

In reality, Gemmas father is Hubbards ex, Turner Kufe, from whom she split in June 2025.

Author: Ethan Caldwell