‘An Unusual Appeal’: Israel’s President comments on Netanyahu’s request for pardon, Mamdani and other topics

Typically, the Israeli presidency is more ceremonial than burdensome, offering prestige without major challenges. Yet the current era has been anything but typical. Israeli President Isaac Herzog shared with POLITICO Magazine the immense emotional and political pressures he has faced since assuming office in 2021.

Herzog has navigated the aftermath of the Covid pandemic, nationwide protests over judicial reforms, and the traumatic impact of Hamas' October 7 attack followed by Israels military response in Gaza. On the horizon looms a pivotal election, where citizens will evaluate Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahus leadershipassuming he remains eligible to run.

Netanyahu is under investigation for corruption, facing potential prison time. He has made an unusual appeal to Herzog: a preemptive pardon before any conviction. The presidential power to grant pardons is one of the few substantial authorities in Israel, and Herzogs decision could spark national controversy. Even abroad, pressure mounts, with former U.S. President Donald Trump publicly urging Herzog to grant the pardon.

Before Netanyahu formally requested the pardon, Herzog praised Trumps efforts, particularly in securing hostages from Gaza, while stressing that pardon decisions are sovereign matters for Israel alone. After receiving Netanyahus request, Herzog confirmed he would evaluate it with utmost seriousness, prioritizing the welfare of the Israeli people.

This weekend, Herzog will travel to New York to receive an honorary degree at Yeshiva University, entering the heart of a highly charged discussion about Israel that resonates with American Jews and broader political circles. Beyond pardons, Herzog addressed topics including Zohran Mamdanis mayoral victory, U.S.-Israel relations, and the prospects for Middle East peace.

U.S.-Israel Relations

Herzog expressed concern about growing skepticism toward Israel among Americans, particularly younger generations influenced by social media narratives. He emphasized shared values between the two nations and highlighted Israels strategic and democratic contributions, while acknowledging challenges in conveying its perspective to a global audience.

Addressing critiques of Israels military actions in Gaza, Herzog stressed adherence to self-defense under international law and the necessity of confronting misinformation. He noted the complexities of public perception shaped by powerful media narratives while affirming Israels commitment to truth and defensive conduct.

The Netanyahu Pardon

Regarding the extraordinary pardon request, Herzog reiterated that it would be evaluated through proper legal channels, focusing on Israels national interest. While acknowledging precedents such as his father granting a preemptive pardon, Herzog underscored that each case must be considered on its own merits, balancing legal equality with unique circumstances.

Herzog also stressed that while he respects Trumps friendship and opinions, Israel remains fully sovereign and bound by its legal system. He avoided speculating on potential consequences of denying the pardon, emphasizing calm, pragmatic relations with the U.S.

Zohran Mamdani and U.S. Politics

Herzog reacted to Mamdanis election in New York by emphasizing that local leadership does not determine Jewish self-determination. He encouraged Mamdani to engage with the diverse perspectives of his city and understand the deep ties many Americans have with Israel.

Domestic Challenges in Israel

Herzog addressed societal divides between religious, secular, and Arab communities in Israel, highlighting their contributions during the war and their role in national dialogue. He stressed the importance of inclusive debate and careful handling of issues such as military service obligations and social integration.

As elections approach, Herzog emphasized his commitment to ensuring fair processes and supporting national unity to confront the countrys many challenges. He expressed cautious optimism about the potential for renewed political discourse, including the viability of the left, amid security concerns and the quest for peace with Palestinians.

Reflections on His Term

Herzog described his tenure as the most challenging in Israeli presidential history, citing the Covid crisis, intense judicial reform debates, and the ongoing fallout from the war. He highlighted the personal toll of meeting over 1,500 bereaved families and supporting citizens affected by conflict, while maintaining pride in serving Israel during this critical period.

Author: Connor Blake