Judges criticize Justice Department for keeping Lindsey Halligan on court documents
- Last update: 12/05/2025
- 3 min read
- 237 Views
- Politics
In Alexandria, Virginia, federal judges have strongly criticized the Justice Department for continuing to include Lindsey Halligan on court documents, with some judges going so far as to remove her name from filings during proceedings. Magistrate judges and a district court judge expressed in open court that Halligan should not appear on new criminal case documents, such as indictments and guilty plea forms, following a recent ruling confirming she is not the US Attorney.
During a criminal case hearing Tuesday, Magistrate William Fitzpatrick stated that submitting criminal charging papers under Halligans name is simply not acceptable at this time. Both Fitzpatrick and Magistrate Michael Nachmanoff highlighted that the district courts ruling clearly established that Halligan had not been confirmed as US Attorney and that the Justice Department had not appealed or sought a stay of the decision.
Judge Cameron McGowan Curries ruling last week determined Halligan was not the US Attorney because she lacked Senate confirmation after 120 days of vacancy and had not been sworn in by the court. The decision also voided her actions in criminal cases against former FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James, both of whom had pleaded not guiltyComey to lying to Congress and James to mortgage fraud.
In a separate hearing Thursday, Nachmanoff ordered Halligans name removed from the case of a Honduran man facing illegal entry charges, citing difficulty reconciling the court ruling with the Justice Departments current actions. During other hearings, Fitzpatrick announced he would strike Halligans name from criminal documents, and Magistrate Lindsey Vaala said she would annotate new indictments to reference the ruling.
The annotations and footnotes now appearing on at least two new indictments clarify Halligans lack of authority in the Comey and James cases. This situation reflects ongoing confusion and a lack of clear guidance from Justice Department leadership, which continues to support Halligan despite the ruling.
Following the dismissals of the cases against Comey and James, the US Attorneys Office has attempted to direct prosecutors on how to sign filings, first instructing them to remove Halligans name and list the top career prosecutor, then reversing the guidance to include Halligan along with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche and the first assistant US Attorney.
Prosecutors have described the Justice Departments instructions as minimal, relying on guidance from the Office of Legal Counsel to maintain Halligans name on filings. Long-time prosecutor Tony Roberts told the court that they are following federal legal counsel guidance despite the unusual circumstances.
Fitzpatrick acknowledged the challenging position of prosecutors, emphasizing the lack of internal guidance and the unfair burden placed on them during court proceedings.
Follow Us on X
Stay updated with the latest news and worldwide events by following our X page.
Open X PageSources:
Author:
Zoe Harrison
Zoe Harrison is a journalist focused on human interest stories and social issues. She excels at crafting compelling narratives and investigative features.
Share This News
Marco Rubio's dangerous attempt to blame Israel for Iran war is self-serving
7 minutes ago 4 min read Politics Riley Thompson
Inspector fired for engaging with sex workers
A former Bedfordshire police inspector has been dismissed after an investigation confirmed he contacted sex workers under the guise of work duties. The inquiry labeled his actions intentional miscondu...
22 hours ago 3 min read Politics Gavin Porter
Texas legislator withdraws from re-election race after confessing to relationship with former employee
Texas Congressman Tony Gonzales has announced he will not seek re election after admitting to a relationship with a former staff member who later died by suicide he will complete his current term whil...
1 days ago 3 min read Politics Lucas Grant
Twelve State Farm Bureaus Join Forces on Labeling in SCOTUS Roundup Case
Twelve State Farm Bureau organizations have filed an amicus brief with the U.S. Supreme Court in the Monsanto v. Durnell case, which could set a major precedent in agricultural law. The case challenge...
1 days ago 5 min read Politics Logan Reeves
Barack Obama Warns of Threats to Fair Elections
Barack Obama has raised concerns about threats to the fairness of elections, specifically highlighting Republican-led redistricting efforts. In a video posted on March 5, he warned that these actions ...
1 days ago 3 min read Politics Logan Reeves
House committee chair seeks prompt testimony from Fed's Powell
The House Financial Services Committee is urging Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell to testify soon, providing lawmakers with crucial insights on the nations economic outlook and monetary policy amid...
2 days ago 3 min read Politics Riley Thompson
Marine Veteran Charged with Criminal Offenses for Breaking Arm Protesting Iran War
Former Marine and firefighter Brian McGinnis has been charged with criminal offenses after a protest at a Senate War Powers Resolution vote, where he broke his arm. McGinnis opposed U.S. military invo...
2 days ago 3 min read Politics Harper Simmons
Justice system undermined as DoJ aligns with Trump's politics amid rising criminal probes
The Department of Justice (DoJ) under former President Donald Trump faces growing criticism for shifting from its role as an impartial legal authority to a politically driven entity. Critics argue tha...
3 days ago 5 min read Politics Olivia Parker
Democrat Representatives Green and Menefee in close competition in newly drawn Texas district
Democratic Representatives Al Green and Christian Menefee are in a tight race for Texas' newly redrawn 18th Congressional District. The district's redistricting has set up a contest between the two in...
3 days ago 3 min read Politics Aiden Foster
US Senate expected to deny attempt to limit Trump's authority on Iran conflict
The US Senate is set to vote on a resolution that would limit President Trump's authority in the Iran conflict. The measure, introduced by Senators Tim Kaine and Rand Paul, mandates the withdrawal of ...
3 days ago 5 min read Politics Lucas Grant