New York Yankees Must Trade These 3 Players

The New York Yankees are facing a critical offseason where roster adjustments seem inevitable. With the team scaling back on free-agent spending compared to past years, trades might be the most effective way to strengthen the squad. Fortunately, the Yankees have a wealth of young talent in their farm system, alongside some big-league players who could become valuable trade assets.

Jasson Dominguez, Outfielder

Jasson Dominguez was once considered a minor league sensation, often compared to legends and nicknamed "The Martian." However, his 2025 season fell short of expectations. Over 429 plate appearances, the 22-year-old posted a .257/.331/.388 slash line with 10 home runs and 47 RBIs, and he struggled in left field, a stark contrast to his earlier reputation as a top defensive center fielder.

With potential free-agent signings like Cody Bellinger or Kyle Tucker, Dominguez may find it difficult to secure a starting outfield spot in 2026. Despite a dip in his stock, his youth keeps his trade value substantial, and other teams may be eager to capitalize on his upside. With Spencer Jones also rising in the farm system, it seems unlikely both outfielders will stay long-term in New York unless free agency falls short.

Will Warren, Pitcher

Once regarded as one of the Yankees top pitching prospects, Will Warren completed his first full big-league season in 2025 with a 4.44 ERA and 9.5 strikeouts per nine innings. At 26, questions about his development ceiling remain. His 2.63 K/BB ratio raised concerns, and he struggled against elite opponents, missing out on a postseason rotation spot in favor of Luis Gil.

With Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodon returning in 2026, and Max Friend, Cam Schlittler, and Gil already in the mix, Warren might not have a long-term rotation role. Trading him now could bring back a frontline starter such as Sandy Alcantara, Freddy Peralta, Joe Ryan, Pablo Lopez, or Tarik Skubal. Controlled through 2030, Warren still has appealing trade value, though it seems unlikely he will reach the top-tier level once projected for him.

Austin Wells, Catcher

Austin Wells quietly posted a tough season in 2025, slashing .219/.275/.436, yet avoided the criticism that befell teammate Anthony Volpe. Since joining the big leagues in 2023, Wells has compiled a .224/.294/.423 slash line. While his defensive skills as a catcher are strong, offensive struggles continue to limit his overall impact.

First baseman Ben Rice, who caught 36 games in 2025 while hitting .836 OPS, could potentially take over behind the plate. Trading Wells could free up flexibility to acquire a major bat at first base, strengthening the lineup overall. Though Wells remains under club control through 2029 and is valued for his defense, the Yankees should seriously consider exploring trade options.

Overall, these three playersDominguez, Warren, and Wellsrepresent prime candidates for trades that could help reshape the Yankees roster and improve their competitiveness for 2026.

Author: Sophia Brooks