Colin Jost Left Scarlett Johansson Feeling 'Flustered' After Their Date

Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost are now considered one of Hollywood's most stable couples, but their romance nearly fizzled out from the very beginning. In a recent appearance on TODAY with Jenna & Friends, Johansson revealed that she unexpectedly cut their first date short, feeling uneasy about the unfamiliar world of casual dating.

The First Date Experience

During the morning show, Johansson recounted sending Jost confusing signals during their initial outing. She explained to co-host Jenna Bush Hager that her history of long-term relationships had kept her away from traditional dating routines. Calling herself a serial monogamist, she admitted that even being asked to dinner felt unusual at the time.

The actress, previously married twice before meeting the Saturday Night Live star, described their first date at a small Italian restaurant in New Yorks East Village. According to Johansson, the evening itself went smoothly, with good conversation and shared laughter.

The Unexpected Twist

The date took an unexpected turn when Jost invited her to join some friends for a drink afterward. Feeling caught off guard, Johansson panicked and decided to leave immediately. I was just like, Ive got to go now. I need to leave, she told Jenna, recalling how she abruptly ended the evening and returned home much earlier than planned. Even her babysitter questioned her early return, to which Johansson could only respond that she felt flustered.

Reconnecting and Building a Relationship

Despite the awkward finish, Jost didnt hold it against her. Johansson shared that he initially assumed she wasnt interested. Fortunately, they decided to give their connection another chance, which eventually blossomed into a nearly decade-long relationship and led to their marriage in 2020.

In his memoir A Very Punchable Face, Jost reflected on his first impressions of Johansson, admitting he felt intimidated by her presence when they met years earlier on SNL. Although he joked about his scruffier appearance at the time, he emphasized how naturally they fit together once they reconnected.

Originally reported by Zahrah Patel on RealityTea, this story highlights the unexpected and human moments that can shape even the most enduring relationships.

Author: Sophia Brooks