Controversy sparked as church replaces Biblical figures in Nativity scene with sign reading ‘ICE was here’

A church in Dedham, Massachusetts, drew attention after it substituted traditional Nativity figures with a sign reading ICE was here, generating strong reactions from locals, including condemnation from a regional religious group. The display at St. Susanna Parish, a Roman Catholic church, replaced Mary, Joseph, and Baby Jesus, as shown in photos shared online.

Alongside the main sign, the church added a second notice providing guidance: The Holy Family is safe in The Sanctuary of our Church. If you see ICE please call LUCE, referring to the LUCE Immigration Justice Network of Massachusetts.

Rev. Stephen Josoma explained to WCVB that the idea originated with him. He said the goal was to highlight the struggles faced by vulnerable populations and prompt reflection on how society treats those in need. We're supposed to bring out the best of people in Christmas, he said.

The display comes amid intensified U.S. immigration enforcement, following the Trump administrations promise to implement the countrys largest deportation initiative. In recent months, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has conducted special operations in major cities, including Boston, just 20 miles from Dedham. Nationwide, ICE arrested 54,000 individuals in November alone.

Photos of the Nativity scene circulated on the churchs Facebook group, generating a mix of responses. Some parishioners expressed gratitude for the display, while C.J. Doyle, Executive Director of the Catholic Action League of Massachusetts, criticized it as divisive and detracting from the core Christmas message.

Pope Leo XIV also expressed concern about the treatment of migrants in the U.S., emphasizing the importance of humane approaches and legal processes, while acknowledging that nations have the right to control entry.

Josoma highlighted the parishs ongoing efforts to assist immigrant resettlement. Many congregants, he noted, face potential danger if deported despite having complied with legal requirements. St. Susanna has previously used its Nativity display to comment on social issues, including a 2018 scene protesting family separation under the Trump administration, which gained national attention.

Despite criticism, Josoma said a significant portion of the community supports the initiative. Its religious art. All art is supposed to move you, he stated, noting that strong reactions are part of confronting difficult realities.

Author: Harper Simmons