Congress blocks NCAA-supported attempt to change college sports regulations

WASHINGTON A major initiative aimed at overhauling college sports regulations, backed by the NCAA, the U.S. Olympic Committee, and the White House, has stalled in Congress. Critics argue the proposed legislation would give excessive authority to the NCAA and its most influential programs.

The bill, known as the SCORE Act, was expected to reach a final vote in the House this week. However, those plans were halted after a procedural vote earlier in the week nearly failed. Some members had questions and wanted more information about the bill, said House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, R-La. We need to ensure the coalition is fully aligned before moving forward.

The legislation, which appeared close to passage over the summer, has repeatedly encountered delays. Scalise did not confirm whether the House would revisit the bill this year, citing a packed legislative agenda.

Supporters Highlight Benefits

Proponents, including the NCAA and Division I conferences, present the SCORE Act as a way to codify rules from a multibillion-dollar lawsuit settlement that allows college athletes to receive compensation. Supporters argue this would provide long-needed clarity and stability in college sports. The White House and the U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Committee have also expressed backing, stating that federal action is necessary to protect student-athletes and maintain collegiate athletic opportunities.

Opposition Raises Concerns

Despite support, the bill faces strong resistance from athletes, unions, and state attorneys general. House Democratic leaders encouraged their members to oppose it, while some Republicans have grown increasingly skeptical, arguing the bill was rushed and that other legislative priorities take precedence.

Critics warn that the legislation would grant sweeping powers to the NCAA and top conferences, including antitrust protections and measures preventing athletes from being classified as employees. AFL-CIO President Liz Shuler described it as union-busting policy in action. The bill would also override state laws regulating payments to college players.

GOP Rep. Byron Donalds of Florida, a gubernatorial candidate, criticized the bill, saying the NCAA is seeking control while college sports revenue continues to grow. Last time I checked, every stadium was full last Saturday. College sports is making more money than ever, yet the NCAA still wants more control, he said.

Legislative Outlook Uncertain

The latest setback occurred after a procedural vote to advance several bills stalled for over an hour due to debate among Republicans. Some lawmakers who previously supported the bill are now reconsidering. I was initially for it. Now Im undecided, said GOP Rep. Anna Paulina Luna of Florida, noting that the legislation is not a top priority at the moment.

With ongoing delays and other urgent legislative matters, including defense authorization and Affordable Care Act subsidy issues, the SCORE Act is unlikely to move forward before the new year. Many Republican members appear reluctant to prioritize helping the NCAA and major conferences, reflecting the evolving dynamics of college athletics under recent NIL changes.

Author: Olivia Parker