Mamdani reveals NYPD commissioner apologized after her brother labeled him 'enemy' of the Jewish people at gala

New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani announced on Thursday that NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch extended a personal apology to his team following controversial comments made by her brother during a prominent Manhattan charity event the previous evening.

Speaking at his Cocoa Chat community meeting, Mamdani confirmed the apology and highlighted his commitment to representing all residents of New York City. "The commissioner expressed regret to my team regarding those statements, and I am dedicated to serving every New Yorker, including Jewish New Yorkers," he said.

He noted that this incident would not disrupt his professional collaboration with Tisch, who will continue to serve as police commissioner despite differences on policy matters. "My discussions with Commissioner Tisch are focused on ensuring public safety while promoting justice across all five boroughs," Mamdani added. "I appreciate the apology, and my attention remains on moving forward with our responsibilities."

An NYPD spokesperson, Brad Weekes, confirmed Tisch's message to the public: "I understand the concerns within the Jewish community. I sincerely believe the mayor-elect will honor his commitment to represent all New Yorkers, including those in the Jewish community."

The controversy arose after Benjamin Tisch, Jessica Tischs brother and CEO of Loews Corporation, called Mamdani an "enemy" of the Jewish people during the Met Councils annual gala at the Mandarin Oriental Hotel. Attendees described the remark as shocking, especially since Commissioner Tisch had agreed to remain in her role under Mamdanis upcoming administration.

Witnesses recounted the moment as causing stunned silence among the audience. Benjamin Tisch has not issued a public statement regarding his comment.

Mamdani, known for his democratic socialist views and criticism of Israel, has repeatedly denied that his positions are antisemitic. Despite policy disagreements, he has expressed confidence in a constructive working relationship with Tisch. "We may have differences on certain topics, but these disagreements are reconcilable and reflect a healthy partnership moving forward," he said.

The Tisch family had previously contributed more than $1 million to political groups opposing Mamdani in the 2025 mayoral race, although Commissioner Tisch did not participate in these donations. The apology from Commissioner Tisch comes just weeks before Mamdanis inauguration scheduled for January 1.

Author’s Analysis: Maintaining Professional Collaboration Amid Controversy

Following the remarks made by Benjamin Tisch at a high-profile Manhattan charity event, New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani confirmed that NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch personally apologized to his team. This gesture underscores the distinction between individual family members’ actions and official duties within city governance.

Mamdani emphasized that the incident will not impede his professional relationship with Commissioner Tisch, who will continue in her role. Discussions between the mayor-elect and the commissioner remain focused on public safety and equitable enforcement across all boroughs.

The controversy highlights the sensitivities surrounding political and community representation, especially concerning New York’s Jewish population. Mamdani’s commitment to inclusive leadership and Tisch’s acknowledgment of community concerns indicate a pragmatic approach to moving forward despite personal or political differences.

While Benjamin Tisch has not issued a statement, Commissioner Tisch’s apology demonstrates accountability within her professional capacity. Both parties appear committed to ensuring that city administration functions without disruption, prioritizing collaboration over discord as the inauguration approaches.

Sources:

• Mamdani says NYPD commissioner apologized after her brother called him 'enemy' of the Jewish people at gala